We offer standard, 3 day express, 2 day express, and overnight express shipping options for your convenience. If you place your order Monday - Friday by 2:00 PM EST using one of our express shipping options, your order will be processed and shipped the same day it is placed!
Applies to delivery within the 48 contiguous states only.
E-Mail Address:
Please Send Me Free Updates via Email
Scratch & dent mystery piece
Officially licensed original replica
Lord of the Rings / The Hobbit
Sold "as is" / no returns
*This item is excluded from express shipping
Scratch & dent mystery piece
Officially licensed original replica
Lord of the Rings / The Hobbit
Sold "as is" / no returns
*This item is excluded from express shipping
Product Description
We have an incredible savings opportunity for our fans of The Lord of the Rings and The Hobbit! We've come across a stash of scratch & dent pieces that we are moving out at incredibly low prices. Each piece is an authentic, officially licensed replica collectible manufactured by United Cutlery. Maybe you'll get Gandalf's staff; perhaps the Sting sword of Bilbo Baggins, the Fighting Knives of Legolas Greenleaf or even some of the original LOTR pieces that were retired years ago! You'll be like a kid opening presents at Christmas when your package arrives. As you know, most of these items retail for hundreds. This scratch & dent sale allows you to own these replicas at a fraction of their retail price.
I received my LOTR mystery scratch and dent item today and am very pleased to find it was Anduril with no major blemishes. The only issue I could find, other than not having the outside cardboard packaging (just the styrofoam), is that the manufacturing stamp was double stamped and illegible. Everything else is perfect. I will definitely buy the LOTR mystery scratch and dent again!
Lukus Therneau Feb 28, 2024 (5 out of 5)
Fantastic
I've been lucky enough to get this twice. The first was Herugrim, with no box but in perfect condition, the second was Narsil, with a crushed box corner, but nothing on the sword. Will absolutely buy again if I can! Thanks BUDK!
Nick Dec 01, 2023 (5 out of 5)
Want to buy this again!
Finally got to order this for the first time, after an attempted purchase earlier in the year was cancelled. So happy to have received Glamdring from the original LOTR trilogy. damage to the outer box and a small dink or 2 on the sword itself, but otherwise perfect! Would love to order again and see what I'll get next time! So happy!
Andrew Sutton May 20, 2022 (5 out of 5)
10/10 would buy again. Because I did.
Bought this S&D box twice. Got a orcrist from the first and got the ringwraith sword the second time. Both times there was very minor damage to the box but I could not find any damage to the swords. Absolutely worth the price.
Terry Tackett Mar 11, 2022 (5 out of 5)
Awesome
I received the witch king sword. Absolutely nothing wrong with it other than a scuff on the box.
Linda White Sep 24, 2021 (5 out of 5)
Excellent Lord of the Rings S&D
I just received my Scratch and Dent package and what a surprise- Anduril and it's scabbard both perfect condition, just packaging banged up.Thanks BUDK
Chad Mayne Feb 07, 2019 (5 out of 5)
Reforged!
I had been watching this one for a awhile and when it became available I struck fast and was fortunate. I received Anduril, the Flame of the West. It is a massive item and the only issues I could find were with the packaging (sword point stop on the bottom was moved so sword had poked from package). After some significant blade polishing (lots of prints) this beautiful item is now hanging from my wall. Another great deal from BudK!
Beau McDermott Nov 02, 2017 (5 out of 5)
War helm of dain
It came in a box that was a little crunched but that was the main thing wrong with it the helm was flawless. thanks BUDK
Anonymous May 02, 2017 (5 out of 5)
Pleased!
Like the previous reviewer, I received Anduril, which is one of the more expensive items in the collection. Needless to say, I came out very well on this deal! I got the item for a fraction of the price. I inspected the item very well and the only flaw I could find was a ring stain on the back of the box. I wouldn't have even noticed it if I had ordered the item new. I was taken aback at how big the sword replica was. I say sword replica because for some reason these reproductions don't come with an edge. I also have the Fighting Knives of Tauriel (I did not buy them through Mystery Scratch & Dent) and they also don't have an edge. I was worried I wouldn't have space to display it because it's so big. It's a beautiful replica. Thanks BUDK for the great deal!
Anonymous Apr 24, 2016 (5 out of 5)
Love my new piece!
Thanks BUDK for another sweet nick and dent sale! I was able to get yet another piece that I don't have with little to no damage! Amazing, I will do this again.
Anonymous Feb 27, 2016 (5 out of 5)
StephenS.
Thanks BudK I recieved my LOR/Hobbit scratch & dent mystery piece the other day. To say I was pleasently surprised is an understatement. I recieved the Mace of Sauron with the One Ring in the expanded size before it shrunk, and the wall hanger for the Mace and the Ring. It hangs on the wall next to Gandalf's staff. Thank you much, a great piece. I look forward to a future purchase when they become avaiable again.
Anonymous Sep 10, 2015 (5 out of 5)
Thanks!
Thank you BUDK for sending me two more amazing deals! I love my new swords. Only missing a plaque on one which is fine with me!
Anonymous Aug 27, 2015 (5 out of 5)
Great luck again!
Thanks BUDK! I was happy to receive two items that only had some slight issues but I am super happy to give them a home! Can't wait to get more of these guys!
michael silvestri Aug 04, 2015 (5 out of 5)
awesome
got gondor shield minor scuffing on the edge...GREAT DEAL...I WANT MORE BUDK.. THANKS
Daniel Alexander Jul 24, 2015 (5 out of 5)
Well worth the money
I received a Sword of Kili. Not a blemish on it that I can find. The box was a little crumpled, but the swrids, mount, and all mounting hardware was intact and pristine. I will definitely be buying more!
Andrew Garrison Jul 23, 2015 (5 out of 5)
Wow!
I got one of these on a whim with a sale, ending up being around $40. I got Anduril! It has a 3-4 mm small 'dremel' like scar near the guard (on the back), but came with the stand, mounting hardware, everything. This is a steal!
jesse Staehler Jul 21, 2015 (5 out of 5)
Great value
Well worth the money!!!!!!!
Anonymous Jul 15, 2015 (2 out of 5)
Good deal
I got a sword it was in great shape. It was missing the wall mounts. But everything else was great.
Showing 3 out of 18
Thanks! This item is in your Cart.
Lord of The Rings / The Hobbit Scratch & Dent Mystery Collectible